Optimization of Acetone Concentration and Reflux Ratio for Enhanced Oil Extraction from Spent Bleaching Earth: A Response Surface Methodology Approach
Article Sidebar
-
Acetone, Oil Extraction, Reflux Ratio, Response Surface Methodology, Spent Bleaching Earth
Abstract
Spent bleaching earth with an oil content exceeding 3% is classified as hazardous and toxic waste, requiring appropriate processing prior to environmental disposal. Extraction is one effective method for processing spent bleaching earth. This study focuses on the optimization of oil extraction from spent bleaching earth using acetone as a solvent, specifically analyzing the effects of solvent concentration and reflux ratio on oil recovery efficiency and evaluating the quality of recovered bleaching earth for potential reuse in vegetable oil refining processes. The extraction method employed was soxhlet extraction using acetone as the solvent. Five different acetone concentrations (50%, 60%, 70%, 80%, and 90%) were tested in combination with five reflux ratios (2, 3, 4, 5, and 6), creating a total of 25 experimental conditions. Response surface methodology (RSM) was utilized to optimize these parameters and identify the ideal conditions for maximum oil recovery. The experimental design and statistical analysis were conducted using Design Expert 13.0.5.0 software. The quality of recovered bleaching earth was assessed against Indonesian National Standards (SNI) for potential reuse applications. The optimization results indicated optimal conditions of 69.15% acetone concentration and a reflux ratio of 4, yielding a maximum oil recovery rate of 17.52%. Analysis of the recovered bleaching earth showed that while it met most SNI standards for bleaching earth quality parameters, the pH remained acidic (below neutral), indicating that alkaline pretreatment would be necessary before the material could be effectively reused in vegetable oil bleaching processes. The study demonstrates that acetone-based soxhlet extraction can effectively recover oil from spent bleaching earth while producing a secondary product suitable for reuse after appropriate pH adjustment.
References
Aldebasir, S. M., A. I. Shehab, and M. A. A. Khalek (2023). Spent Bleaching Earth; Recycling and Utilization Technique: A Review. Journal of Resources, Conservation, & Recycling Advances, 17; 200124
Bachmann, S. A. L., R. D. C. S. C. Valle, A. A. Vegini, and L. B. B. Tavares (2020). Determination of Optimum Conditions for Thermal Regeneration and Characterization of a Spent Bleaching Earth. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 8(2); 103503
Bayram, H., G. Ustunisik, M. Önal, and Y. Sar?kaya (2021). Optimization of Bleaching Power by Sulfuric Acid Activation of Bentonite. Clay Minerals, 56(2); 148–155
Carré, P., S. Bothe, C. D. Borah, T. Piofczyk, and S. Hadjiali (2025). Solvent Solutions: Comparing Extraction Methods for Edible Oils and Proteins in a Changing Regulatory Landscape. Part 5: Impacts on the Oil Quality. OCL, 32; 6
Darmawan, M. A., B. Z. Muhammad, A. F. P. Harahap, M. Y. A. Ramadhan, M. Sahlan, H. Haryuni, T. Supriyadi, S. Abd-Aziz, and M. Gozan (2020). Reduction of the Acidity and Peroxide Numbers of Tengkawang Butter (Shorea stenoptera) Using Thermal and Acid Activated Bentonites. Heliyon, 6(12); e05742
Dejkajorn, C., P. Suttiarporn, H. Sukkathanyawat, K. Wichianwat, S. Sriphan, and T. Srisurat (2021). Optimization of Microwave-Assisted Extraction of Residual Soybean Oil from Spent Bleaching Earth. E3S Web of Conferences, 302; 01009
Handoko, O. T., U. Hasanudin, E. Suroso, D. Dermiyati, S. D. Yuwono, S. B. Ginting, R. Sugiharto, L. Indraningtyas, J. R. Amelia, and D. A. Iryani (2024). Economic and Environmental Analysis of Spent Bleaching Earth Reactivation. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 1308(1); 012061
Indonesian Nasional Standarization Agency (2000). SNI:13-6363-2000 Bentonite for Vegetable Oil Bleaching
Latisya, S., N. S. Indrasti, and M. Muslich (2024). Reactivation of Used Bentonite (Spent Bleaching Earth) and Its Reuse as Adsorbent for CPO (Crude Palm Oil) Bleaching Process. BIO Web of Conferences, 99; 02013
Maged, A., S. Kharbish, I. S. Ismael, and A. Bhatnagar (2020). Characterization of Activated Bentonite Clay Mineral and the Mechanisms Underlying Its Sorption for Ciprofloxacin From Aqueous Solution. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 27(26); 32980–32997
Manimaran, R., K. M. M. Kumar, and N. S. Narayanan (2020). Synthesis of Bio-Oil From Waste Trichosanthes cucumerina Seeds: A Substitute for Conventional Fuel. Scientific Reports, 10(1); 17815
Merikhy, A., A. Heydari, H. Eskandari, and A. Nematollahzadeh (2019). Revalorization of Spent Bleaching Earth a Waste From Vegetable Oil Refinery Plant by an Efficient Solvent Extraction System. Waste and Biomass Valorization, 10(10); 3045–3055
Naser, J., O. P. Avbenake, F. N. Dabai, and B. Y. Jibril (2021). Regeneration of Spent Bleaching Earth and Conversion of Recovered Oil to Biodiesel. Waste Management, 126; 258–265
Oladosu, W. A., Z. A. Manan, and S. R. W. Alwi (2017). Recovery of Vegetable Oil From Spent Bleaching Earth: State-of-The-Art and Prospect for Process Intensification. Chemical Engineering Transactions, 56; 133–138
Placxedes, S., M. Mamvura, T. Tirivaviri, A. Abdulkareem, S. Ambali, G. Danha, and G. Gwiranai (2024). Spent Bleaching Earth: Synthesis, Properties, Characterisation and Application. Journal of Sustainability Science and Management, 19(3); 192–220
Plata, V., Ó. Rojas, and P. Gauthier-Maradei (2020). Improvement of Palm Oil Biodiesel Filterability by Treatment with Reactivated Spent Bleaching Earths. Fuel, 260; 116198
Sabour, M. R. and M. Shahi (2018). Spent Bleaching Earth Recovery of Used Motor-Oil Refinery. Civil Engineering Journal, 4(3); 572
Saini, R. K., P. Prasad, X. Shang, and Y. Keum (2021). Advances in Lipid Extraction Methods–A Review. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 22(24); 13643
Soetaredjo, F. E., L. Laysandra, J. N. Putro, S. P. Santoso, A. E. Angkawijaya, M. Yuliana, Y. H. Ju, C. H. Zhou, and S. Ismadji (2021). Ecological-Safe and Low-Cost Activated-Bleaching Earth: Preparation, Characteristics, Bleaching Performance, and Scale-Up Production. Journal of Cleaner Production, 279; 123793
Tetrisyanda, R. and G. Wibawa (2022). Feasibility Aspect in Utilizing Spent Bleaching Earth Waste for Briquette, Fertilizer and Oil Recovery. Materials Today: Proceedings, 63; S84–S88
Yao, L., X. Fan, C. Yan, T. Kurtén, K. R. Daellenbach, C. Li, Y. Wang, Y. Guo, L. Dada, M. P. Rissanen, J. Cai, Y. J. Tham, Q. Zha, S. Zhang, W. Du, M. Yu, F. Zheng, Y. Zhou, J. Kontkanen, and F. Bianchi (2020). Unprecedented Ambient Sulfur Trioxide (SO3) Detection: Possible Formation Mechanism and Atmospheric Implications. Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 7(11); 809–818
Yuan, Z., Y. Shen, H. Yuan, A. Sui, and N. Zhu (2020). A Collaborative Approach to In-Situ Oxysulfides and Oxynitrides Fixation in Flue Gas and Energy Recycling: Co-combustion of Spent Bleaching Earth and Coal. Journal of Cleaner Production, 258; 120622